ChangeWTC7

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Saturday, 24 December 2011

Strawman?

Posted on 09:50 by Unknown
One of the most common claims of the increasingly inaccurately named 9/11 Truth movement is that of a "strawman" argument.  This claim is assisted by the fact that no two truthers can agree on much, but the fact is that a fair amount of people can be found who support even the most idiotic claim, unfortunately.  This recent article on the AE911Truth site attacking Chris Mohr could be Fisked at great length, but hey, it is Christmas and I have better things to do, but I thought I would point out this "Strawman" claim.  Feel free to debunk the rest of the article in the comments between opening presents and drinking hot cocoa.

• If 4500 degree nanothermites were used to pulverize almost every inch of every concrete floor, then how could there have been millions of sheets of paper with an ignition temperature of only 451° raining down on the sidewalks?

This is a strawman argument. To my knowledge, nobody has suggested that nano-thermite was used “to pulverize almost every inch of every concrete floor.” To bring the building down, the steel load-bearing columns would have to be cut and gravity would do the rest. No nano-thermite or explosives would be used on the floors at all. Any use of nano-thermite would be targeted at the connections or the columns themselves.

Unfortunately for the author, this is a common claim in the movement, for this claim we have to go no further than AE911Truth founder Richard Gage himself, here for example in a radio interview from March 2008:


Ninety thousand tons of struct... of concrete has been pulverized to a fine talcum powder, though these uhh, intense explosions, including its metal decking and the floor trusses that were supporting, it, uhh completely gone and blown outside the perimeter.

Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • The Pony Remains....
    According to the Troofers , not the magistrate: Charged with not paying his TV licence, Tony Rooke had claimed at Horsham Magistrates’ Cour...
  • Fan Mail
    It is amusing to get e-mails from readers who have just discovered our blog, and act like they have unveiled our nefarious plot forever.  Th...
  • Vote Now!
    The advertising choices for Operation Tilting at Windmills are available now.  How democratic that they let the common man decide what type...
  • Hilariously Bad Truther Cultural Analysis
    I suppose I shouldn't be surprised, after all these were the brainiacs who argued that Muslims are not allowed to wear jewelry and were ...
  • The Eichenwald Article on Other PDBs
    My feeling is that it's a tad overdramatic ; on the other hand it is intended to sell a book. Key paragraph: The direct warnings to Mr....
  • The Org Chart From Hell
    Sometimes the Truthers make our points better than we can make them ourselves. In this case, we have always pointed out how ridiculously com...
  • Box Boy Rakes in $75,000
    Our buddy Joseph Nobles (aka Boloboffin) reports : $75,450 Richard Gage’s salary in 2009 from Architects & Engineers for 9/11 Truth. Tha...
  • The New Debunker on the Block
    None other than Al Qaeda : In the latest issue of the al Qaeda English-language magazine "Inspire", an author appears to take of...
  • What is Old is New Again
    It took several years, but now the "science" of 9/11 has returned to the early days of Sophia and "clunkity clunk".  Fro...
  • Damn, Missed It
    Well, Richard Gage came to Seattle last week, and as a result... uhh... well, absolutely nothing happened. No mention in the media, or any t...

Categories

  • "Truthers" (3)
  • 11th Day (1)
  • 9-11 Debunkers (1)
  • 9-11 Deniers (2)
  • 9-11 Investigation (1)
  • 9-11 Rebunkers (1)
  • 9-11 Warnings (2)
  • Active Thermitic Materials (1)
  • Advice Columnists (1)
  • Airfones (1)
  • Alan Grayson (1)
  • Alec Baldwin (1)
  • Alex Jones (8)
  • Alive Hijackers (1)
  • Amanda Keller (1)
  • Among the Truthers (5)
  • Anders Behring Breivik (1)
  • Andrew Napolitano (4)
  • Andrew Wakefield (1)
  • Anthony J. Hall (1)
  • Anthony Lawson (2)
  • Anthony Summers (1)
  • anti-semitism (3)
  • Anti-Vaxxers (1)
  • anti-Zionism (1)
  • April Gallop (7)
  • Architects and Engineers (5)
  • Ballot Initiative (1)
  • Behrooz Sarshar (1)
  • Bentham Open Journals (4)
  • Bob McIlvaine (2)
  • Boston Marathon (1)
  • Brian Good (4)
  • British Truthers (1)
  • Bruno Bruhwiler (1)
  • Building What (1)
  • Byron Williams (1)
  • Celebrity Kooks (7)
  • Charlie Sheen (4)
  • Chris Mohr (5)
  • Cindy Sheehan (3)
  • Citizen's Investigative Team (4)
  • Coast To Coast (3)
  • Coleen Rowley (1)
  • Colorado Nutbars (3)
  • Comic books (1)
  • Conspiracy Nutbars (1)
  • Conspiracy Theories (1)
  • Conspiracy Theories TV Show (2)
  • Cosmos (1)
  • crazy theories (2)
  • Daniel Hopsicker (1)
  • Dave Thomas (3)
  • David Aaronovitch (1)
  • David Chandler (1)
  • David Griscom (2)
  • David Ray Griffin (12)
  • Deathers (1)
  • Debate Challenge (2)
  • Debates (1)
  • Debunking 9-11 (1)
  • Debunking Videos (1)
  • Democrats (1)
  • Dick Gregory (1)
  • Disconnecting the Dots (1)
  • Donna Marsh O'Connor (1)
  • Dorothy Lorig (1)
  • Doug Stanhope (1)
  • Dumb Quotes (1)
  • Dylan Avery (1)
  • Ed Asner (1)
  • Eric Lawyer (1)
  • Fiascos (1)
  • Firefighters for Troof (1)
  • Flight 11 (1)
  • Flight 175 (1)
  • Flight 77 (1)
  • Flight 93 (1)
  • Fox News (1)
  • Frank Legge (1)
  • Free Gaza Movement (1)
  • Gareth Newman (1)
  • George Tenet (1)
  • Geraldo Rivera (3)
  • Glenn Zarmanov (2)
  • Guy Razer (1)
  • Hacking Scandal (1)
  • Holocaust Denial (5)
  • Ian Crane (1)
  • Ian Henshall (1)
  • Infowars (1)
  • Insider Trading (1)
  • Irish TV (1)
  • Iron Man (1)
  • James David Manning (1)
  • James Fetzer (1)
  • Jared Loughner (2)
  • Jason Bermas (1)
  • Jason Leopold (1)
  • Jesse Ventura (5)
  • Jew-bashing (1)
  • Jim Corr (1)
  • Jim Fetzer (1)
  • John Wright (1)
  • Jon Cole (1)
  • Jon Gold (10)
  • Jonathan Kay (9)
  • Joshua Blakeney (2)
  • Journal of 9/11 Studies (2)
  • Judge Napolitano (1)
  • Karen S. Johnson (1)
  • Karl Rove (1)
  • KBDI (2)
  • Kent Knudson (1)
  • Kevin Barrett (4)
  • Kevin Fenton (2)
  • Kevin McPadden (1)
  • Kevin Ryan (5)
  • Khalid Sheikh Mohammed (1)
  • Korey Rowe (1)
  • Kristen Breitweiser (1)
  • Lenny Dykstra (1)
  • LIHOP (1)
  • Loose Change American Coup (1)
  • Loose Change debunked (1)
  • Loose Change errors (1)
  • Loose Change lies (1)
  • Louis Farrakhan (1)
  • Mahmoud Ahmajinedad (2)
  • Manny Badillo (2)
  • Mark Ruffalo (1)
  • Matt Naus (1)
  • Matt Taibbi (2)
  • Media (1)
  • Michael Shermer (3)
  • Mickey Rothenberg (1)
  • Mike Gravel (1)
  • Miles Kara (1)
  • Millette Study (1)
  • Missing Staircases (1)
  • Mr Rational (1)
  • Nanothermite (3)
  • Nation of Islam (4)
  • National Geographic (1)
  • National Security Alert (1)
  • Neils Harritt (5)
  • News of the World (1)
  • Newscorp (1)
  • NIST (1)
  • No-Planers (1)
  • Noam Chomsky (1)
  • NORAD (2)
  • Norwegian Shooting (1)
  • Obama Birthers (1)
  • Osama bin Laden (3)
  • Other Debunkers (1)
  • Paul Craig Roberts (1)
  • Paul Watson (1)
  • Paul Zarembka (1)
  • Peer Review (3)
  • Pentagon (3)
  • Phil Jayhan (1)
  • Philip Shenon (1)
  • Philip Zelikow (1)
  • Phone Calls (1)
  • Political Candidates (1)
  • President Bush (1)
  • Press for Truth (1)
  • psychedelics (1)
  • Put Options (1)
  • Radio (1)
  • Relationships (1)
  • Rich Veitch (1)
  • Richard Clarke (1)
  • Richard Falk (2)
  • Richard Gage (28)
  • Robbyn Swan (1)
  • Roseanne Barr (3)
  • Rosie O'Donnell (1)
  • Rupert Murdoch (1)
  • Ryan Mackey (1)
  • Sander Hicks (1)
  • Scootle Royale (1)
  • September Clues Busted (1)
  • Sibel Edmonds (3)
  • South Park (1)
  • Steve Alten (1)
  • Steven Jones (10)
  • Street Actions (1)
  • the Simpsons (1)
  • Thierry Meyssan (1)
  • Tony Szamboti (1)
  • Troofer Weddings (1)
  • Truther Arrests (1)
  • Truther Convicts (1)
  • Truther Murderers (5)
  • Truther Nuts (1)
  • Truther Politicians (1)
  • TruTV (1)
  • Unsecured Coins (1)
  • Voice-Morphing (2)
  • We Are Change (1)
  • Webster Tarpley (1)
  • Wikileaks (1)
  • William Veale (1)
  • Willie Rodriguez (4)
  • WTC 7 (1)
  • WTC-7 (1)
  • Zeitgeist (2)
  • Ziad Jarrah (1)

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (50)
    • ►  December (1)
    • ►  September (2)
    • ►  August (5)
    • ►  July (4)
    • ►  June (5)
    • ►  May (4)
    • ►  April (11)
    • ►  March (5)
    • ►  February (6)
    • ►  January (7)
  • ►  2012 (84)
    • ►  December (5)
    • ►  November (4)
    • ►  October (4)
    • ►  September (8)
    • ►  August (5)
    • ►  July (8)
    • ►  June (9)
    • ►  May (6)
    • ►  April (8)
    • ►  March (8)
    • ►  February (11)
    • ►  January (8)
  • ▼  2011 (270)
    • ▼  December (10)
      • Yet Another Sign It's Over
      • Strawman?
      • A Spot of Silly Debunking
      • What is Old is New Again
      • Flight 93 Boarding Passes
      • Mapping the Truther Mind (sic)
      • Lawyers for 9/11 Tru... Oh look, a Squirrel!
      • Occupy Wall Street Protestor Who Got A Job On Wall...
      • Is It Over?
      • Eloquence in Support of Gage's Gaggle
    • ►  November (12)
    • ►  October (17)
    • ►  September (35)
    • ►  August (22)
    • ►  July (22)
    • ►  June (29)
    • ►  May (31)
    • ►  April (21)
    • ►  March (21)
    • ►  February (24)
    • ►  January (26)
  • ►  2010 (96)
    • ►  December (25)
    • ►  November (16)
    • ►  October (19)
    • ►  September (22)
    • ►  August (14)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile